Tor network DDoS attack overwhelms most relays, fix released
Part of the Tor story · since 15 Nov
- Sun 15 Nov, 23:08 UTC. cybersixt, first report. Tor network DDoS attack overwhelms most relays, fix released. This article, 1st of 1.
The Tor anonymity network is under a sustained distributed denial-of-service attack that has affected most of the volunteers who run its relays, the Tor Project says. On 13 November it shipped Tor 0.4.9.17, a security release it described as a "rapid response to the ongoing DDoS attack on the network", and asked every relay operator to upgrade as soon as possible.
"This is not an easy problem to address, as relays across the network are being overwhelmed by a massive flood of client circuits," the project wrote. It said one fix in the release is especially important for relay DoS defences related to IPv6 handling, that it is evaluating more defences, and that it expects further releases soon. No action is needed after upgrading.
A second attempt at a fix
It is the second defensive release in just over two weeks. On 28 October the project released Tor 0.4.9.15 with three new defences against what it called the "BEGIN_DIR thunderstorm attack": floods of BEGIN_DIR cells, the requests relays use to fetch directory documents such as the network consensus, sent over circuits. The main one is a per-circuit rate limit on those requests, switched on by default and tuned through network-wide consensus parameters.
That did not end the attack. On the tor-relays mailing list, one operator wrote on 13 November that a BEGIN_DIR flood had bypassed what they called the incomplete fix in 0.4.9.15, and that several distinct attacks were running, "probably because the attacker is trying to determine the cheapest and most effective one". Another reported around 200,000 TCP connections to their relay against a normal 2,000 to 8,000.
What operators are seeing
After upgrading to 0.4.9.17, an operator who had already lost two relays' HSDir flags to the attack reported on 14 November that the update reduced the flood hitting one relay, but that about ten minutes later the attack switched to a different pattern: traffic fell almost to nothing while the relay logged a stream of "relay unresponsive" messages, until it lost its HSDir flag and the attack stopped. Relays with that flag store the descriptors that let Tor clients find onion services. The operator concluded that the mitigations in 0.4.9.17 were not enough to protect HSDir relays.
For people using Tor, a flood that exhausts relays can mean slower or failing circuits. The Tor Project has not published figures on how much the attack has degraded the network for users.
What relay operators should do
The Tor Project asks relay operators to upgrade to 0.4.9.17 now and to leave the new DoS settings to the consensus rather than setting them by hand. Operators are sharing measurements and firewall rules on the tor-relays list, and the project has thanked them for that work.
What is not known
The Tor Project has not said who is behind the attack, what it is meant to achieve, how many relays have dropped out, or how much it has slowed the network for users.
How the story developed
1 article from 1 outlet since 15 Nov. Still developing; the latest report was 24 hours ago. This was the first report.
- Sun 15 Nov, 23:08 UTC. cybersixt, first report. Tor network DDoS attack overwhelms most relays, fix released. This article, 1st of 1.
- No CVE
- Larger: an outlet’s first report
- Coverage over time
Show all 1 articles as a listHide the list
- Sun 15 NovDay 01
- Tor network DDoS attack overwhelms most relays, fix released23:08 · cybersixt · First report · This article, 1st of 1
Sources
- Tor Project: Security Release 0.4.9.17Primary sourceforum.torproject.org
- Tor Project: Tor 0.4.9.15 released with new DoS defensesPrimary sourceforum.torproject.org
- tor-relays: operators report BEGIN_DIR flood bypassing 0.4.9.15forum.torproject.org
- tor-relays: update on attack after the 0.4.9.17 upgradeforum.torproject.org
More reporting
- Suspected Optimizely breach planted card stealer on 186 websites16 Nov
- BundID cyberattack locks German accounts, email codes now required16 Nov
- Trezor data breach at shipping partner exposes 27,000 orders16 Nov
- Fugaku supercomputer hit by cyberattack, users' SSH keys stolen16 Nov
- Lighter DEX exploit drains $10.4M via a trader's leaked API keys16 Nov
Written by CyberSIXT from the sources above.How we reportCorrectionsRSS